WE ARE OPEN! Real Old-Fashioned Hard Ice Cream

Located inside of Johnny Ad's on Boston Post Rd. in Old Saybrook, CT
910 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT
Header image for the site



5 months ago
My first visit to Fenwick Ice Cream Co. was delectable. The variety of ice cream wasn't enormous but generally enough to make a decision difficult. I had the Mud Pie (coffee based ice cream with hot fudge and caramel swirls, chocolate covered almonds and oreos). Absolute delicious. The server (I believe was the owner) was courteous, funny and very accommodating!!
- Cynthia D
2 months ago
Home town feel and the bestest of I've cream I ever did have 😃😃
- Clif B
6 months ago
Great ice cream! Lots of topping choices and friendly service. Thanks!
- Jeffrey R

About Us

Fenwick Ice Cream Co. is locally owned and operated. Handmade in Connecticut for over 30 years, the ice cream we serve has been voted “Best Made Ice Cream in CT” by Connecticut Magazine four times. 

Follow us on Facebook and Instagram @fenwickicecreamco

Contact us: fenwickicecreamco@gmail.com

Flavor List:
Coffee, Toasted Almond, Pistachio, Butter Pecan, Mint Chip, Coconut, Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter, Peach, Oreo, Black Raspberry, Cotton Candy, Cookie Dough, Vanilla Chocolate Chip, Coffee Oreo, Coffee Chocolate Chunk, Cookie Monster, Key Lime Pie, Chocolate Mousse, Mississippi Mud, Coffee Caramel, Orange Sherbert, Black Raspberry Yogurt, Watermelon Sorbet, Strawberry, Chocolate, Vanilla

We also offer sundaes, banana splits, and sell Ice Cream Pies!

Contact Us


Call now
  • (860) 391-5167


Get directions
910 Boston Post Rd
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
United States
Contact Us
Message sent. We'll get back to you soon.